The mascara ranked near the top for lengthening lashes and not irritating eyes and earned the highest score for smooth application, separating lashes and not flaking. "Lengthened and lifted my lashes well," a tester commented. "I have sensitive eyes, and this mascara did not irritate them." While it goes and stays on easily, a few reviewers noted that the formula can be hard to remove. Why We Love It: For Matin, it’s all about Neutrogena’s Healthy Volume Mascara with its nourishing ingredients a